Tips for A Successful Employee of the Month Program
A monthly recognition program is a powerful way to boost gratitude in your clinic — but be sure to do it right.
In the fast-paced, high-pressure world of clinic operations, the concept of Employee of the Month can feel like an outdated relic—a dusty plaque in the lobby that no one pays attention to. For many busy healthcare leaders, it’s seen as a feel-good gesture, not a strategic tool.
Yet, a well-designed recognition program is one of the most effective strategies you can deploy to drive employee engagement in clinics, improve patient care, and reduce healthcare turnover. The key is to transform it from a popularity contest into a structured, value-driven feature that reinforces the very best of your clinic’s culture.
This guide will show you how to master a strategic recognition program, turning a simple monthly award into a force for healthcare staff retention.
1. Eliminate the "Beauty Contest" with a Selection Panel
The moment your Employee of the Month program becomes a popularity contest, it loses credibility. Staff will nominate their friends or the most visible people, ignoring the often-unsung heroes of the back office or the reliable, consistent performers who drive your clinic's stability.
Establish a Multi-Role Panel: Base your decision on a panel of 3-5 leaders (e.g., a Practice Manager, a Lead Nurse/Tech, and a Physician or Owner). This eliminates the "beauty contest" problem and ensures diverse perspectives are considered.
Set Criteria for Quality Nominations: The panel should evaluate submissions based on quality and detail, not sheer volume. Encourage staff to share their full thoughts, but make it clear that submissions like "She's great!" will not carry weight. Your team should be looking for examples that demonstrate specific behaviors.
Here’s how you can communicate this: Tell staff that the strongest nominations clearly describe what the employee did and what impact it had on a patient, a coworker, or a clinic metric (e.g., "Jane stayed an extra hour to fix the credentialing file, preventing a billing hold").
Audit for Representation: Ensure your program is equitable by tracking who is being nominated and selected across different departments, roles (e.g., clinical vs. administrative), and shifts. The panel’s role should include correcting any unconscious bias that favors visible roles (like the front desk) over critical back-office functions. Consistent fairness is key to HR compliance for medical practices.
Vary the Selection Criteria: A single amazing performance might be a great reason to celebrate an employee. But it also might be worth celebrating someone for their consistency and reliability. Be open to recognizing different types of performance because good performance comes in many forms.
2. Maximize the Impact: Tying Recognition to Clinic Value
Recognition is powerful only when it is amplified and connected back to the results that matter to your practice. Don't just hand over a gift card; tell a story that reinforces your core values and operational goals.
Make it a High-Visibility Event: How you promote the winner is key. Take a high-quality photo of the winner (perhaps with the nominating manager or physician) and make it a big deal. Send an email to all staff, post it on social media (with consent), and put it up on a dedicated recognition board in the breakroom.
Tie the Action to Clinical Success: Always connect the employee's behavior to a positive outcome relevant to your clinic: "This month, we are highlighting Sarah for her tireless work that helped achieve a 100% success rate on difficult prior authorizations, directly impacting revenue" or "Victor’s compassionate demeanor with a nervous patient reduced their anxiety before surgery, boosting satisfaction scores."
Recognize the Nominator and Honorable Mentions: This is an overlooked but crucial element! Make sure you highlight the employees who were nominated but not chosen for the honor (the "honorable mentions") and praise the nominators, as well. Recognizing more people reinforces a culture of appreciation and encourages future submissions.
3. Designing Flexible and High-Impact Rewards
A great recognition program needs great prizes, but they don't need to be expensive. And the dollar value isn’t necessarily the main driver of impact.
Keep Cash Prizes Modest (Under $100): While cash, pins, or gear are great, keeping the value around or under $100 prevents people from becoming too focused on "winning." The primary value should be in the recognition and spotlight, not the dollar amount.
Offer Flexibility and Work-Life Balance Perks: Sometimes the most valuable reward is time or convenience.
Offer the "Golden Parking Spot" for the month.
Grant an extra paid day off to their PTO balance.
Provide a complimentary lunch for their work team in their honor.
Implement Annual, Elevated Recognition: Beyond the monthly spotlight, consider selecting one or more employees for annual recognition with an extra special gift. This is a great way to announce your top-tier contributors at a holiday meeting or employee summer picnic, further cementing your culture of appreciation and improving healthcare staff retention.
Ready to transform your employee recognition into a tool that drives growth and reduces HR challenges in healthcare? Let's connect. Contact me today to explore ways I can help.
Free HR Resources for Ophthalmology Clinics
Complete the form and immediately get ALL of my free downloadable resources.
BONUS - Subscribers who sign up for news and updates will get a biweekly newsletter with HR updates, leadership tips, and more.
To get it - sign up now!
